TCLA's School Accountability Report Card Series: Reports

Fighting the Battle of the Books: TCLA Report Card Issue #3

>> Continued from the home page for Issue #3

Joshua fi't the battle of Jericho; and we fi't the battle of the books. At first, we had none at all. If we asked, the white folks would say that the children "wouldn't read 'em if they had 'em." We didn't think that. When the county did start to furnish books, the children had to rent them in the fall and turn them back in the spring, and we never got a new book to give out, in return for the fee. Even so, the books never would go around to everybody. Most had to look on. I'll tell you something else that I saw in my day: segregated books. The County library truck used to come around with colored and white stacks—in other words a stack of old books and a stack of new.

— Mamie Garvin Fields, Lemon Swamp and Other Places

Mamie Garvin Fields taught in the sea islands off South Carolina during the first decades of the 20th century. In classrooms crowded with as many as 60 children, Mrs. Fields encouraged her students to embrace the power of education to liberate the mind and spirit. She also struggled, with equal parts tenacity and creativity, to better the conditions her students faced. She "fought the battle of the book" in many ways--soliciting resources from her own community, defying county rules, and confronting the White school officials. She took these actions to make sure her students could read and "to make each child understand that he was somebody."

In this issue of TCLA, students, parents, and teachers join the 'battle of the books' by reporting on access to learning materials within their own schools. Parent advocates in South Gate decided to conduct a student survey on learning materials after reading their official School Accountability Report Card or SARC. Given the experiences of their own children at South Gate High School, parents couldn’t accept the SARC’s claim that there are "sufficient numbers of textbooks to support the school's instructional program." The parents’ survey confirmed their fears. 69% of South Gate High School students surveyed reported that they do not have a set of textbooks in all their classes. 70% responded that they do not have textbooks that they can take home.

Unfortunately, these conditions extend beyond South Gate. A survey conducted at Lynwood High School produced similar results. 77% of students do not have textbooks in all their classes; 60% do not have books to take home. In addition, only 25% reported that they have access to decent quality dictionaries and thesauruses in their English and History classes. Even fewer—less than 7%—have a computer and printer in all their classes.

Photo: Mamie Garvin Fields

Photo/Mamie Garvin Fields from
Lemon Swamp and Other Places: A Carolina Memoir
(New York: Free Press, 1983)

Because Fremont High School students have access to computers in their classrooms, they were able to respond to TCLA’s online inventory of classroom learning materials. They rated their computers 'fair,' but their textbooks 'poor.' The Fremont students also provided a list of needed learning materials — from graphing calculators to a wider variety of literature books. The common sense insights of the Fremont students raise a set of questions: Why don't school officials encourage all students to provide this sort of information? Why don't we have an educational system that insures decent learning materials for all students? Why do so many still need to fight the battle of the books?

Here is the publications Calendar for TCLA’s Virtual School Report Card Series:

Dates of Publication by Issue Submissions Deadline
1. Nov.1 – Introducing the School Report Card Friday 10/18
2. Dec. 20 – Mission & Description Friday 11/27
3. Feb.10 – Conditions for Quality Learning Friday 1/31
4. March 31– High Quality Teaching Friday 3/14
5/6. June 10 – Double Issue: Learning & Assessment, Safe & Democratic School Environment Friday 6/9
7. August 18 – Youth/Parent Summit Issue Friday 7/18