TCLA's School Accountability Report Card Series: Features: 3

Why Must School Be Boring?

Invigorating the Curriculum with Youth Culture

UCLA researcher Jeff-Duncan Andrade offers resources on the use of hip-hop and rap text to successfully teach literacy skills to high school English students.

Photo: The Lyricist Lounge Vol.1 presents Mos Def featuring Q-Tip & Tash

I wanted my students to see that the texts they were choosing to access were really quite similar to the texts that they often rejected as irrelevant.

As a teacher in Oakland, I regularly witnessed my students’ intense investment in multiple areas of youth popular culture (music, film, sport, style, etc.). Inside of these cultural spaces, students would often display the same academic literacy skills that I was asking them to produce in the classroom (critique, analysis, oral presentation). Sadly, these skills often did not transfer into academic success in most of their classes. However, I discovered that this performance gap could be bridged by incorporating youth culture into the curriculum.

In July 2002, my colleague, Dr. Ernest Morrell, and I published an article that documented our use of rap texts in our Oakland high school English classroom. For over six years, we have been sharing this strategy of incorporating youth culture into the curriculum with teachers and teacher educators around the country. This past month, the Los Angeles Times ran an article that discussed our work, along with the work of several high school teachers that are currently using hip-hop texts in their classrooms.

This dialogue has stirred the public debate in the media about the appropriateness of using rap lyrics in the classroom (see New York Post article, LA Times article and O'Reilly Factor transcript.) Since the publication of the L.A. Times article, Dr. Morrell and I have discussed and debated this topic on the Fox News Network, ABC Radio, National Public Radio and have been contacted by the Washington Post about a follow up article. While this discussion of innovative teaching practices is important in the public sphere, it is often not thorough enough to be meaningful to classroom teachers. To bring more teachers into this dialogue, we encourage teachers, students and parents to share their views on the use of youth culture in the curriculum. We invite interested readers to submit any resources or comments that they feel are relevant to this topic. At the bottom of this page, I have listed several links that might be useful for this on-going conversation.

Hip Hop Album Covers: Mos Def, The Coup, & Dead Prez

A Teaching Philosophy

My students came to my classroom with many of the skills that I was expected to teach them. They could analyze text. They could develop and support an argument. They understood concepts of theme, characterization, rhyme, rhythm, meter and tone. I watched them display these skill sets almost every day when they would talk about things that were relevant to them as teenagers—this is what I refer to as youth culture. However, I also saw my students frequently internalizing and falling prey to popularized negative images of urban youth as menaces from the margins. They often passively received these media messages through their youth culture, and so they remained unclear about ways that they could critique and disrupt these lowered expectations of them.

I believed to my core that a rigorous curriculum could be a marriage of youth culture and canonical culture, and that this would bring the vigor and vitality of my students back into the classroom.

To bridge this gap between youth culture and the culture of my classroom, I began with one basic premise. I worked from the notion that a classroom curriculum does not have to be boring to students. I shuddered at the idea that school was a place where students had to sacrifice themselves and the things they enjoyed to pursue “real knowledge”. This idea rested on the basic assumption that a central tenet of good teaching is to find ways to make learning fun—strangely, we seem to violate this time honored wisdom with remarkable regularity. At the most basic level, this meant learning about the interests of my students and then finding ways to incorporate them into virtually every aspect of my class.

I did not, however, want my class to become a live version of “The Box” ( a popular music video channel). I wanted my students to see that the texts they were choosing to access were really quite similar to the texts that they often rejected as irrelevant. I believed to my core that a rigorous curriculum could be a marriage of youth culture and canonical culture, and that this would bring the vigor and vitality of my students back into the classroom.

In addition to increased student engagement, this approach to teaching also works nicely to create meaningful assessments of student learning. Like the curriculum itself, the academic assessments (debates, court trials, presentations) drew heavily upon the cultural strengths of my students (argument, reflection and critique) as a bridge into the academic literacies (textual analysis, critical literacy, developing and supporting oral and written arguments) demanded of them from the academy. These activities acted as a scaffold into advanced level writing exercises (opening/closing arguments for debates/court trials, psychoanalytical critiques of film characters vs. novel characters, original poetry using classic forms) that allowed students the opportunity to show more traditional representations of their academic literacy skills.

^tcla

Link For more on this debate:

English Journal article:
http://www.ncte.org/ej/abstracts/0916-july02/promoting.shtml

L.A. Times article:
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/la-me-hiphop14jan14001442.story

New York Post link (dissenting opinion):
http://www.vdare.com/malkin/hiphop.htm

O’Reilly Factor:
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,76329,00.html

--------------------

Talk Back Talk Back: Continuing the Discussion

I offer this brief explanation of my philosophy as a way to start a conversation. I would like to encourage an open exchange and critique of ideas and classroom units in the hope that we can more effectively spread and understand effective practice in our schools. TCLA is also interested in creating an on-line space for teachers to share their work and the work of their students that draw upon youth culture (music, sport, film, style, language). Please submit your contributions with “Youth Culture” in the subject line to tcla@gseis.ucla.edu or use the Talk Back form to send us your ideas.